I define emotional engagement as being made to laugh a lot, be anxious in a good way, or straight up bawl my eyes out. If it makes me think about the narrative years later, than it is in my top VN.

  1. Mystic Messenger did all three multiple times. <3 Unknown bad ends made me sob for an hour in the base game. Then I bought the after story, got a bad end, and sobbed for another hour. How can I keep failing you my love? v_v XD
  2. Cinderella Phenomenon: pushed all my difficult parental relationship buttons and literally made me reach out to reconnect with my dad. <3 Rod, I cried so hard at his bad end, oh my gosh.
  3. Gilded Shadows: I cried once but it was a good happy cry of relief. <3 Quill, Jack, Lance & Ari. One route hasn’t been released yet of the 9.
  4. Akash: Path of the Five. Only VA work I’ve ever bothered listening to. <3 Nate, Rocco, and Lux.
  5. Changeling: I just liked the lore of the world. It’s already so long and I wish it was longer on some routes. <3 William
  6. Oathbreaker 1/2: The continuity and mature themes really touched and impressed me. Having moving scenes where a lover cries in your arms is beautiful. <3 Virion
  7. Animal Lover: This had interesting concepts that were best exhibited by the hamster-turned-man I romanced, Edmund. What is it like to live forever, to lose yourself, to find yourself again, and find what’s important about the self. Warning: Character suicide I didn’t see coming at all that left me dealing with some emotions for about an hour.
  8. Arcade Spirits: depression, finding a passion, finding somewhere you fit in, and fighting for it. The sexy dancer, Teo, was a bonus.
  9. Royal Alchemist: I liked that I could pick the femme looking boy and skip the frilly dress and still keep she/her pronouns. I was invested and the story took turns I didn’t expect. <3 Aurelius for making me want to so badly best him at sword fighting.
  10. Crimson Spires: The MC is an FBI agent that is pulled into a retrieval mission for a prisoner that was being transported to trial. And then they were like, interesting idea. Let’s destroy it with mysterious alien towers and vampires and let you romance the bad guys. <3 August for making me do the impossible and root for a serial killer.
  11. Ebon Light: The amount of self expression as well as affection levels with the love interests were great. I told a guy I needed to think about whether or not we should be romantic. They accepted it and brought it up later- asked whether I had made up my mind. <3Haron & Vadeyn
  12. Love Ritual: This seemed pretty standard but then Dom/Sub moving explicit sex scenes and the plot twist toward the end got me. Woof. <3 Shanrae
  13. Love Spell: Written in the Stars- Sometimes immature, but I adored the mascot best friend there were some very actiony routes that kept me on the edge of my seat. <3 Florian and Enix
  14. Veil of Dust: Focus is actually on your sibling and farming, with LIs being optional side content. Can play as brother or sister. I was obsessed with Stardew for a long time right when they came out, so I was fond of the farming mechanic. And I wouldn’t give up hugging the brother. <3 Laan
  15. Steam Prison: Couldn’t put the game down because I found the world lore fascinating. <3 Ulrik
  16. Silhouette: So short (<3 hours) but I was giggling a lot, and then I got downright teary eyed thinking I’d gotten a bad ending that turned round at the last second. <3 Derrick

Unfinished but author has recent content updates:
The Survival of Sarah Rose 18+ content is constant but avoidable. It’s a dark dark world and Sarah can rise above it or wallow in it. So many branches, like, wow. <3 Atilla the orc and wins all around for female representation of healthy masturbation habits.

Happy to elaborate if my blurbs aren’t enough in the comments. :) I’ve read over 100, but these are the ones that made me get attached.

@catch42