yjk@lemmy.catoLemmy.ca's Main Community@lemmy.ca•[New Rule discussion] No Editorializing Article Titles. The original title of the article must be used.English
11·
1 year agoI don’t mean to be nitpicking but if the rule is zero-tolerance I think we should clear up the edge cases. I hope you don’t take this the wrong way.
- What happens when the original title is misleading or clickbait? Personally I like how HN handles things in this case (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html).
- How about if you want to ask a question about a news article as the main focus of the post, but also want to include context about the article?
- Or if you’re making the post to discuss a related topic, and include multiple articles?
- On that note, what even counts as a news article? What if I post a link to a reddit thread about a news article?
While we’re at it, can we ban amp links and other url tracking in general?
No punishment for doing it, but maybe have a bot to remind people.
To clarify, I’m not engaging in whataboutism, I think both of them should be banned (though maybe sometimes affiliate links have their place).