Things got heated on the piracy community at lemmy.dbzer0.com when the admin, db0, announced plans to use a GenerativeAI tool to rotate the community’s banner daily with random images.
While some praised the creative idea, others strongly objected, arguing that AI-generated art lacks soul and meaning. A heated debate ensued over the artistic merits of AI art versus human-created art.
One user threatened to unsubscribe from the entire instance over the “wasteful BS” of randomly changing the banner every day. The admin defended the experiment as a fun way to inject randomness and chaos.
Caught in the crossfire were arguments about corporate ties to AI image generators, electricity waste, and whether the banner switch-up even belonged on a piracy community in the first place.
In the end, the admin stubbornly insisted on moving forward with the AI banner rotation, leaving unhappy users to either embrace the chaotic visuals or jump ship. Such is the drama and controversy that can emerge from a seemingly innocuous banner change!
— Claude, Anthropic AI
Some extra context: db0 has already been using AI for their banners since the start, and so the announcement itself is just that they plan to have it generate new ones daily.
I believe that people did not know of this, which is why people are debating it now. (I do not know if there was an announcement made at the time)
I apologize for weird wording, I typed this on mobile.
db0 has been all-in on using AI for announcement banner artwork, moderation, csam protection (Overseer) and this and that since last summer. I think these are useful and good ways to apply AI. It takes out a lot of the gritty labour that would need to otherwise be done by unpaid volunteers anyway.
Dunno why people are fussing about it. I mean sure, stealing art might be more in spirit with the piracy community but it a daily rotating banner seems so benign that it could be just as easy to ignore.
SEETHE DILATE HOT POCKETS HOT POCKETS DILATE COPE CITY SLICKER SNEED’S JANNY HOT POCKETS FUCK FUCK SNEED’S CHUCK CHUCK ON LEMMY FEED CITY SLICKER FOR FREE SEED SEED SNEED’S FLOYD CHUCK HOT POCKETS FOR FREE FEED JANNY SUCK JANNIES FUCK FEED CLEAN IT UP FUCK CHUCK COPE SEETHE CITY SLICKER SNEED’S JANNY CHUCK CHUCK FUCK FOR FREE I CAN’T HOT POCKETS CLEAN IT UP CHUCK’S CITY SLICKER ON LEMMY
SNEED’S FUCK CLEAN IT UP CHUCK’S JANNIES SNEED FEED I CAN’T CHUCK’S HOT POCKETS CLEAN IT UP FUCK HOT POCKETS SEED CITY SLICKER SUCK CHUCK CHUCK CHUCK’S FLOYD HOT POCKETS JANNIES JANNY SNEED SUCK FOR FREE CHUCK FLOYD CHUCK’S FEED CLEAN IT UP SEETHE I CAN’T CITY SLICKER FUCK I CAN’T COPE CLEAN IT UP JANNY CITY SLICKER JANNY DILATE SNEED FLOYD CHUCK’S COPE ON LEMMY JANNIES SNEED’S FUCK